Thursday, January 23, 2014

Luna gave a “State of the Borough”…But not really



Today’s Community News stated that Tony Luna gave an “end of the year report” at the Lodi council work session on January 14.  I was the only member of the public present at the work session.  No newspaper reporters were present.

Tony Luna NEVER gave a “State of the Borough” or end of year report.  In fact, when it was time for him to give his monthly Manager’s Report, he handed the council a sheet of paper so he wouldn’t have to discuss his report publicly.  He never provided a copy to the public (me).  This is no way to run a public meeting. 

So why would Luna break tradition and not discuss his Manager’s Report publicly?  Because last year his tax/spending claims were questioned and debunked.  So this year, he skipped all conversation on the matter and fed the Community News a press release.

The press release sounded so good, I would vote for this administration if I didn’t know better.  But I do know better.

Luna has nothing to brag about with regard to municipal taxes.  In 2013, Lodi had the second highest effective tax rate in all of Bergen County.  There are 70 towns in Bergen County.

These charts speak for themselves:


Tony Luna wants to blame all the tax increase on the Lodi Board of Education.  Even if that were the case, the Lodi council is one in the same with the BOE and have blurred all lines of separation on the tax bill.  You have the same few families sitting on the council and the BOE.  You have council members employed in our schools and board members employed in the borough hall.  You have a combined number of 14 “Yes” people on both bodies controlled by Tony Luna and Joseph Capizzi.  They raise taxes together.

The Lodi BOE is responsible for a lot of the tax increases but not all.  Just look at municipal spending over the last 2 years.  In 2012, municipal spending was $24,581,470.29.  It 2013, it rose to $25,280,227.65.  That was an increase of $698,757. 36 or a 2.84% increase.  Yes, their spending surpassed 2% from 2012 to 2013.  And municipal taxes increased at a time when Lodi saw its council bonding millions of dollars for the most basic expenses.  They gave Lodi more taxes and more debt.

And some of the things Luna says just don’t make sense.  Take this quote from today’s paper:


"ShopRite, the new Lodi Mall and the WaWa complex alone have added $18,647,400 to our assessed value. Our ratables on these projects alone are $592,987,000. This would be comparable to the taxes received on 658 homes paying taxes of $9,000 each," said Luna.

If those businesses combined added $18,647,400 to our assessed value, then they would be paying a combined $592, 987.32 in taxes, not $592, 987,000.  The tax rate for Lodi in 2013 was 3.18.  And 658 homes paying $9,000 each would be paying $5,922,000.  So none of the three figures match up.  And his figures are in quotation marks so I am sure they came from him.


And Shoprite was built by 2007.   Luna included it as a 2013 achievement.